Yes or No

danixsaur · Subject: Re: Yes or No Sun Nov 16, 2008 2:54 am

I just finished this book about 10 minutes ago. I already loved this book the most, I didn't even have to finish it yet. Its a very close tie between this book and Twilight. I thought this book was so sweet in the beginning, with the wedding and the honeymoon...and then when Bella said she was prego I was like WTF? And then to me it got very very weird. I was like this book is crazy!!! I was a bit angry at first that Bella confided in Rosalie, because I was with Jacob in thinking she just wanted the baby and didnt care for Bella. I was even a bit worried that Bella would die, but deep in my heart I knew she was going to live.
I flipped to the back of the book to see how many pages it had and stumbled upon the list of all the covens...I read the Cullens and I saw "Renneseme" I was like AW MAN!! It ruined the surprise of the sex of the baby, b/c I hadn't gotten to that part yet. It was then confirmed that Bella lived and that the baby was a girl. I was a bit dissapointed but not too much. I covered it up with a post-it note so when I loan it to my friend the same thing wont happen to her, haha.

I predicted that Jacob imprinted Nessie. I knew it at the exact moment that he said Rose held her up and he saw her face. I was proud of myself when I figured it out, haha...it sucks that I wasn't surprised about it though.

I thought the chapters with the confrontation with the Volturi was long and drawn out, a bit boring, but other than that, I loved this book and think its almost perfect!

Alice is one of my favorite characters and I felt so betrayed when she left. And when Bella went to the J dude and got the documents I was like oh no, this book is going to turn out tragic. I was pleasantly surprised that the Volturi chickened out.

I love this book!!

_________________

Lusty · Subject: Re: Yes or No Sun Jan 04, 2009 6:22 pm

danixsaur wrote:

I thought the chapters with the confrontation with the Volturi was long and drawn out, a bit boring

Yea I have to agree....plus the whole Volturi-chickening-out-at-the-last-minute bit seemed kinda anti-climatic to me. But overall I really enjoyed Breaking Dawn

hannah141627 · Subject: Re: Yes or No Wed Jan 07, 2009 4:01 pm

i love the frst "book" in breaking dawn but I'm not too keen on the jacob bits i would rather they had been doe from edwards point of view

hannah141627 · Subject: Re: Yes or No Wed Jan 07, 2009 4:07 pm

Xtremeangel wrote:

And so well written! Although I would like more Edward, but I think that for every book! lol!
scratch

i thought it should have more edward too

cklover42 · Subject: Re: Yes or No Wed Jan 28, 2009 7:30 pm

I agree the battle or lack there of at the end was EXTREMELY anticlimatic but at the same time I think it needed to be done. The Volturi do still keep order. You dont have to like them...I dont....but without them the south and most vampires unlike th Cullens would wreak havoc so even though I wanted Emmett to finally get to beat up Demetri I knew it ended right.

_________________

hannah141627 · Subject: Re: Yes or No Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:52 pm

hell yh emmett should have gotten a chance to beat up demetri

i ownz edward · Bitten Number of posts: 5 Registration date: 2009-03-31

[b]
Well i agree wid u cause it was the best
i knw all of it was so romantic
i knw this is kinda weird but i lke the way Jacob imprints on Renesme.
ILY! breaking dawn

chronicles_fan32 · Subject: Re: Yes or No Fri Apr 03, 2009 7:36 am

I feel there should of been some sort of battle. It seemed to be building up to that and then just let down. I enjoyed the book but there should have been a final battle.

TwilightLulu82 · Subject: Re: Yes or No Fri Apr 03, 2009 2:04 pm

I think and I am guessing here, Maybe the reason there wasn't a battle was Stephenie didn't want any of her characters to die. I mean in a battle like that would have been some people would have died. Just an opinion!

_________________

courtneyBABY · Subject: Re: Yes or No Fri Apr 03, 2009 5:55 pm

I have to say this book is my 2nd favorite. i know alot of people dont like New moon but its honestly my favorite.. then breaking dawn lol i thought Jacob's chapter titles were funny.

cklover42 · Subject: Re: Yes or No Fri Apr 03, 2009 6:31 pm

For me it was Twilight, Eclipse, Breaking Dawn, and New Moon is that book that I am not very fond of but was a must read to continue the series. I hope she finally finishes Midnight Sun because not having a book with Edward's POV in it would be ridiculous. You get Bella's hell you even get Jacob's. I want Edward's!

_________________

Kenzie · Subject: Re: Yes or No Mon Apr 06, 2009 7:29 pm

Ah it's so hard for me to put my favorites in order... I try to but then I'm like oh wait but I love this so much about this book... lol it's impossible for me

_________________

cklover42 · Subject: Re: Yes or No Mon Apr 06, 2009 8:32 pm

For me Eclipse and Breaking Dawn are a tie but Twilight is my favorite and New Moon is in dead last

_________________

danixsaur · Subject: Re: Yes or No Tue Apr 07, 2009 3:20 pm

I love them all.

I am currently reading Twilight for the 7th time? lol

Twilight its my favorite, but when I say that, I always think of the other books and why i love them too. Its hard to pick a favorite. New Moon is very sad and depressing but it is still a great book, Eclipse is good but I would say it my least fave out of the series. I like Breaking Dawn a whole lot, its so hard to choose.

_________________

Kenzie · Subject: Re: Yes or No Thu Apr 09, 2009 10:44 pm

I know, it's like impossible... I usually say Twilight's my favorite but then I think about all the other ones...

_________________