|
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
Maria Cullen
True Twilighter
Number of posts: 1367
Age: 33
Location: Looking for my Edward/Emmett
Registration date: 2008-08-26
 |  Subject: Re: Yes or No  Sun Aug 31, 2008 12:03 pm | |
| I loved this one, The wedding was amazing & made me cry. I had so many OMG moments, Her pregnancy, Almost dying having the baby, Jacobs imprinting, Alice & Jazz leaving. I cried like a baby when Bella & Edward were saying goodbye to Renesmee. The whole book was awesome, I so wanted to e Bella living in the cottage with Edward ! |
|
  | |
Teffy
Bitten
Number of posts: 129
Age: 29
Registration date: 2008-08-27
| | Subject: Re: Yes or No Sun Aug 31, 2008 2:11 pm | |
| OMG I cried to when they were saying goodbye to Renesmee!!! I would've liked it if Edward had a little more 'book time' with her. It seemed like she was pretty much always with Bella, Rosalie, or Jacob. I was SO upset when Alice left. Like...upset enough to almost put the book down (I read that part after my other post in this thread about everything coming full circle..LOL). But then, when she came back I actually shouted out loud! LOL! |
|
| | |
Tamran
Administrator
Number of posts: 1677
Age: 35
Location: Memphis, TN
Registration date: 2008-08-25
| |
| | |
Kenzie
Whoa! Over Breaking Dawn
Number of posts: 827
Location: Iowa
Registration date: 2008-08-26
| |
| | |
Maria Cullen
True Twilighter
Number of posts: 1367
Age: 33
Location: Looking for my Edward/Emmett
Registration date: 2008-08-26
| | Subject: Re: Yes or No Mon Sep 01, 2008 11:13 am | |
| | Teffy wrote: | OMG I cried to when they were saying goodbye to Renesmee!!! I would've liked it if Edward had a little more 'book time' with her. It seemed like she was pretty much always with Bella, Rosalie, or Jacob.
I was SO upset when Alice left. Like...upset enough to almost put the book down (I read that part after my other post in this thread about everything coming full circle..LOL). But then, when she came back I actually shouted out loud! LOL! |
I did the same thing, I actually cant believe how completely obsessed I have become with the Twilight books. I felt lost when I finished. |
|
| | |
Kenzie
Whoa! Over Breaking Dawn
Number of posts: 827
Location: Iowa
Registration date: 2008-08-26
| | Subject: Re: Yes or No Mon Sep 01, 2008 11:15 am | |
| exactly how I felt. When I had to wait for like a day before I could start reading again....ooh it was bad. |
|
| | |
Jayla
Bitten
Number of posts: 17
Age: 29
Location: NYC
Registration date: 2008-09-06
| |
| | |
Maria Cullen
True Twilighter
Number of posts: 1367
Age: 33
Location: Looking for my Edward/Emmett
Registration date: 2008-08-26
| |
| | |
TwilightLulu82
True Twilighter
Number of posts: 2414
Age: 27
Location: Jacksons underwear drawer sniffin his undies!
Job/hobbies: Slacker/Student
Humor: Insane, Sarcastic, Loud
Registration date: 2008-08-27
| |
| | |
obsessed
Twilight Lover
Number of posts: 379
Location: chicago
Job/hobbies: waiting for my edward
Registration date: 2008-08-27
| | Subject: Re: Yes or No Sun Sep 14, 2008 10:18 pm | |
| | Jayla wrote: | | Kenzie wrote: | | Seriously why DID some people complain about it? I swear I couldn't find one single problem with it... |
People were complaining about the fact that everything wound up perfectly for Bella in the end. Basically, she got everything she wanted- she was happy, Renesmee survives, Jacob's happy, her family is happy, etc. People apparently think that sends the wrong message to the young readers- like stuff never turns out this neatly in real life.
I adored the book, I've read it three times. I tend to skip over Jacob's part, because I really just don't like him, but the rest of the book I thought was great.
I mean come on...it's a book about vampire love and shape-shifters...what kind of message do you REALLY want it to send?  |
i definitely agree_________________ [img]  [img]  [/img][img]  [/img] |
|
| | |
danni4hardyz
Bitten
Number of posts: 121
Age: 37
Location: Australia
Registration date: 2008-08-28
| | Subject: Re: Yes or No Tue Sep 16, 2008 9:02 am | |
| The only thing that was a bit hard to get used to was the back and forth from Bella to Jake. I would have preferred it just to be through her eyes. But at the same time it was really cool to see it through his too. I guess I am not making sense! I will say that I loved this book more and more as I got through it, so much so that I read it in 24 hours lmfao I am so mentally drained but in a good way! I feel complete now. But I will read them all again of course, they have changed my life, honestly. I love them all for different reasons. I found Bella much less annoying in this book, so much more mature. I mean the one thing I would have done different if I were Bella during the whole series, was say yes when he wanted to marry me! I was like, what the hell are you thinking Bella, say yes to this godly creature! But it all ends well, I think she ended it well. He finally got to hear her, the best gift she could give him, herself. |
|
| | |
TwilightLulu82
True Twilighter
Number of posts: 2414
Age: 27
Location: Jacksons underwear drawer sniffin his undies!
Job/hobbies: Slacker/Student
Humor: Insane, Sarcastic, Loud
Registration date: 2008-08-27
| |
| | |
Nadine
New Moon Fan
Number of posts: 545
Age: 30
Registration date: 2008-08-27
| | Subject: Re: Yes or No Tue Sep 16, 2008 12:08 pm | |
| LOL yeah i loved reading it from jakes point of view. i thought it was good. hahah the before car...yeah that was good. _________________  |
|
| | |
obsessed
Twilight Lover
Number of posts: 379
Location: chicago
Job/hobbies: waiting for my edward
Registration date: 2008-08-27
| | Subject: Re: Yes or No Tue Sep 16, 2008 12:54 pm | |
| | TwilightLulu82 wrote: | | Yeah the bouncing back and forth in this one was really annoying but I did like seeing Jakes point of view. I love the part in the begining when she driving her "Before car" she was hilarious. I was literally yelling at the book when she didn't automatically say YES to his proposal. |
I know!! i was like, "SAY YES!! what are you thinking!?!"_________________ [img] [img] [/img][img] [/img] |
|
| | |
TwilightLulu82
True Twilighter
Number of posts: 2414
Age: 27
Location: Jacksons underwear drawer sniffin his undies!
Job/hobbies: Slacker/Student
Humor: Insane, Sarcastic, Loud
Registration date: 2008-08-27
| |
| | |
|
and for some reason I actually thought Stephenie wasn't going to bring her back; I thought it might have been why so many people don't like the book. So I was crying again when she came back lol but very happy crying...lol.
